[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":1008},["ShallowReactive",2],{"stoic-author-seneca":3,"stoic-editions-work-on-benefits":68,"stoic-sections-work-195":102,"stoic-content-547-2306":998,"stoic-section-topics-2306":1007},{"id":4,"name":5,"shortName":6,"urlSlug":7,"birthYear":8,"deathYear":9,"nationality":10,"summary":11,"moreInfoUrl":12,"works":13},208,"Lucius Annaeus Seneca the Younger","Seneca","seneca",-4,65,"ES","Roman Stoic philosopher, statesman and dramatist","https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seneca_the_Younger",[14,19,24,28,31,35,39,43,47,51,56,60,64],{"id":15,"name":16,"urlSlug":17,"editionCount":18},195,"On Benefits","on-benefits",3,{"id":20,"name":21,"urlSlug":22,"editionCount":23},199,"On the Happy Life","on-the-happy-life",1,{"id":25,"name":26,"urlSlug":27,"editionCount":23},201,"On the Firmness of a Wise Man","on-the-firmness-of-a-wise-man",{"id":4,"name":29,"urlSlug":30,"editionCount":23},"Moral Letters to Lucilius","letters",{"id":32,"name":33,"urlSlug":34,"editionCount":23},205,"On Consolation - To Helvia","on-consolation-to-helvia",{"id":36,"name":37,"urlSlug":38,"editionCount":23},204,"On Consolation - To Marcia","on-consolation-to-marcia",{"id":40,"name":41,"urlSlug":42,"editionCount":23},206,"On Leisure","on-leisure",{"id":44,"name":45,"urlSlug":46,"editionCount":23},200,"On Peace of Mind","on-peace-of-mind",{"id":48,"name":49,"urlSlug":50,"editionCount":23},203,"On Consolation - To Polybius","on-consolation-to-polybius",{"id":52,"name":53,"urlSlug":54,"editionCount":55},202,"On the Shortness of Life","on-the-shortness-of-life",2,{"id":57,"name":58,"urlSlug":59,"editionCount":23},198,"On Clemency","on-clemency",{"id":61,"name":62,"urlSlug":63,"editionCount":23},197,"On Anger","on-anger",{"id":65,"name":66,"urlSlug":67,"editionCount":23},196,"On Providence","on-providence",[69,83,93],{"id":70,"name":71,"year":72,"language":73,"publication":74,"publicationCountry":75,"author":76,"work":82},547,"Of Benefits","1889","eng",null,"GB",{"id":77,"name":78,"shortName":79,"urlSlug":80,"deathYear":81},210,"Aubrey Stewart","Stewart","stewart",1918,{"id":15,"name":16,"urlSlug":17},{"id":84,"name":71,"year":85,"language":73,"publication":74,"publicationCountry":75,"author":86,"work":92},572,"1578",{"id":87,"name":88,"shortName":89,"urlSlug":90,"deathYear":91},213,"Arthur Golding","Golding","golding",1606,{"id":15,"name":16,"urlSlug":17},{"id":94,"name":16,"year":95,"language":73,"publication":74,"publicationCountry":75,"author":96,"work":101},573,"1569",{"id":97,"name":98,"shortName":99,"urlSlug":100,"deathYear":74},214,"Nicolas Haward","Haward","haward",{"id":15,"name":16,"urlSlug":17},[103,107,111,115,119,123,127,131,135,139,143,147,151,155,159,163,167,171,175,179,183,187,191,195,199,203,207,211,215,219,223,227,231,235,239,243,247,251,255,259,263,267,271,275,279,283,287,291,295,299,303,307,310,314,318,322,326,330,334,338,342,346,350,354,358,362,366,370,374,378,382,386,390,394,398,402,406,410,414,418,422,426,430,434,438,442,446,450,454,458,462,466,470,474,478,482,486,490,494,498,502,506,510,514,518,522,526,530,534,538,542,546,550,554,558,562,566,570,574,578,582,586,590,594,598,602,606,610,614,618,622,626,630,634,638,642,646,650,654,658,662,666,670,674,678,682,686,690,694,698,702,706,710,714,718,722,726,730,734,738,742,746,750,754,758,762,766,770,774,778,782,786,790,794,798,802,806,810,814,818,822,826,829,832,835,838,841,844,847,850,853,856,859,862,866,869,873,876,880,884,887,890,894,898,902,906,910,914,918,922,926,930,934,938,942,946,950,954,958,962,966,970,974,978,982,986,990,994],{"id":104,"label":105,"sortOrder":106},2179,"1.01",14,{"id":108,"label":109,"sortOrder":110},2180,"1.02",15,{"id":112,"label":113,"sortOrder":114},2181,"1.03",16,{"id":116,"label":117,"sortOrder":118},2182,"1.04",17,{"id":120,"label":121,"sortOrder":122},2183,"1.05",18,{"id":124,"label":125,"sortOrder":126},2184,"1.06",19,{"id":128,"label":129,"sortOrder":130},2185,"1.07",20,{"id":132,"label":133,"sortOrder":134},2186,"1.08",21,{"id":136,"label":137,"sortOrder":138},2187,"1.09",22,{"id":140,"label":141,"sortOrder":142},2188,"1.10",23,{"id":144,"label":145,"sortOrder":146},2189,"1.11",24,{"id":148,"label":149,"sortOrder":150},2190,"1.12",25,{"id":152,"label":153,"sortOrder":154},2191,"1.13",26,{"id":156,"label":157,"sortOrder":158},2192,"1.14",27,{"id":160,"label":161,"sortOrder":162},2193,"1.15",28,{"id":164,"label":165,"sortOrder":166},2194,"2.01",29,{"id":168,"label":169,"sortOrder":170},2195,"2.02",30,{"id":172,"label":173,"sortOrder":174},2196,"2.03",31,{"id":176,"label":177,"sortOrder":178},2197,"2.04",32,{"id":180,"label":181,"sortOrder":182},2198,"2.05",33,{"id":184,"label":185,"sortOrder":186},2199,"2.06",34,{"id":188,"label":189,"sortOrder":190},2200,"2.07",35,{"id":192,"label":193,"sortOrder":194},2201,"2.08",36,{"id":196,"label":197,"sortOrder":198},2202,"2.09",37,{"id":200,"label":201,"sortOrder":202},2203,"2.10",38,{"id":204,"label":205,"sortOrder":206},2204,"2.11",39,{"id":208,"label":209,"sortOrder":210},2205,"2.12",40,{"id":212,"label":213,"sortOrder":214},2206,"2.13",41,{"id":216,"label":217,"sortOrder":218},2207,"2.14",42,{"id":220,"label":221,"sortOrder":222},2208,"2.15",43,{"id":224,"label":225,"sortOrder":226},2209,"2.16",44,{"id":228,"label":229,"sortOrder":230},2210,"2.17",45,{"id":232,"label":233,"sortOrder":234},2211,"2.18",46,{"id":236,"label":237,"sortOrder":238},2212,"2.19",47,{"id":240,"label":241,"sortOrder":242},2213,"2.20",48,{"id":244,"label":245,"sortOrder":246},2214,"2.21",49,{"id":248,"label":249,"sortOrder":250},2215,"2.22",50,{"id":252,"label":253,"sortOrder":254},2216,"2.23",51,{"id":256,"label":257,"sortOrder":258},2217,"2.24",52,{"id":260,"label":261,"sortOrder":262},2218,"2.25",53,{"id":264,"label":265,"sortOrder":266},2219,"2.26",54,{"id":268,"label":269,"sortOrder":270},2220,"2.27",55,{"id":272,"label":273,"sortOrder":274},2221,"2.28",56,{"id":276,"label":277,"sortOrder":278},2222,"2.29",57,{"id":280,"label":281,"sortOrder":282},2223,"2.30",58,{"id":284,"label":285,"sortOrder":286},2224,"2.31",59,{"id":288,"label":289,"sortOrder":290},2225,"2.32",60,{"id":292,"label":293,"sortOrder":294},2226,"2.33",61,{"id":296,"label":297,"sortOrder":298},2227,"2.34",62,{"id":300,"label":301,"sortOrder":302},2228,"2.35",63,{"id":304,"label":305,"sortOrder":306},2229,"3.01",64,{"id":308,"label":309,"sortOrder":9},2230,"3.02",{"id":311,"label":312,"sortOrder":313},2231,"3.03",66,{"id":315,"label":316,"sortOrder":317},2232,"3.04",67,{"id":319,"label":320,"sortOrder":321},2233,"3.05",68,{"id":323,"label":324,"sortOrder":325},2234,"3.06",69,{"id":327,"label":328,"sortOrder":329},2235,"3.07",70,{"id":331,"label":332,"sortOrder":333},2236,"3.08",71,{"id":335,"label":336,"sortOrder":337},2237,"3.09",72,{"id":339,"label":340,"sortOrder":341},2238,"3.10",73,{"id":343,"label":344,"sortOrder":345},2239,"3.11",74,{"id":347,"label":348,"sortOrder":349},2240,"3.12",75,{"id":351,"label":352,"sortOrder":353},2241,"3.13",76,{"id":355,"label":356,"sortOrder":357},2242,"3.14",77,{"id":359,"label":360,"sortOrder":361},2243,"3.15",78,{"id":363,"label":364,"sortOrder":365},2244,"3.16",79,{"id":367,"label":368,"sortOrder":369},2245,"3.17",80,{"id":371,"label":372,"sortOrder":373},2246,"3.18",81,{"id":375,"label":376,"sortOrder":377},2247,"3.19",82,{"id":379,"label":380,"sortOrder":381},2248,"3.20",83,{"id":383,"label":384,"sortOrder":385},2249,"3.21",84,{"id":387,"label":388,"sortOrder":389},2250,"3.22",85,{"id":391,"label":392,"sortOrder":393},2251,"3.23",86,{"id":395,"label":396,"sortOrder":397},2252,"3.24",87,{"id":399,"label":400,"sortOrder":401},2253,"3.25",88,{"id":403,"label":404,"sortOrder":405},2254,"3.26",89,{"id":407,"label":408,"sortOrder":409},2255,"3.27",90,{"id":411,"label":412,"sortOrder":413},2256,"3.28",91,{"id":415,"label":416,"sortOrder":417},2257,"3.29",92,{"id":419,"label":420,"sortOrder":421},2258,"3.30",93,{"id":423,"label":424,"sortOrder":425},2259,"3.31",94,{"id":427,"label":428,"sortOrder":429},2260,"3.32",95,{"id":431,"label":432,"sortOrder":433},2261,"3.33",96,{"id":435,"label":436,"sortOrder":437},2262,"3.34",97,{"id":439,"label":440,"sortOrder":441},2263,"3.35",98,{"id":443,"label":444,"sortOrder":445},2264,"3.36",99,{"id":447,"label":448,"sortOrder":449},2265,"3.37",100,{"id":451,"label":452,"sortOrder":453},2266,"3.38",101,{"id":455,"label":456,"sortOrder":457},2267,"4.01",102,{"id":459,"label":460,"sortOrder":461},2268,"4.02",103,{"id":463,"label":464,"sortOrder":465},2269,"4.03",104,{"id":467,"label":468,"sortOrder":469},2270,"4.04",105,{"id":471,"label":472,"sortOrder":473},2271,"4.05",106,{"id":475,"label":476,"sortOrder":477},2272,"4.06",107,{"id":479,"label":480,"sortOrder":481},2273,"4.07",108,{"id":483,"label":484,"sortOrder":485},2274,"4.08",109,{"id":487,"label":488,"sortOrder":489},2275,"4.09",110,{"id":491,"label":492,"sortOrder":493},2276,"4.10",111,{"id":495,"label":496,"sortOrder":497},2277,"4.11",112,{"id":499,"label":500,"sortOrder":501},2278,"4.12",113,{"id":503,"label":504,"sortOrder":505},2279,"4.13",114,{"id":507,"label":508,"sortOrder":509},2280,"4.14",115,{"id":511,"label":512,"sortOrder":513},2281,"4.15",116,{"id":515,"label":516,"sortOrder":517},2282,"4.16",117,{"id":519,"label":520,"sortOrder":521},2283,"4.17",118,{"id":523,"label":524,"sortOrder":525},2284,"4.18",119,{"id":527,"label":528,"sortOrder":529},2285,"4.19",120,{"id":531,"label":532,"sortOrder":533},2286,"4.20",121,{"id":535,"label":536,"sortOrder":537},2287,"4.21",122,{"id":539,"label":540,"sortOrder":541},2288,"4.22",123,{"id":543,"label":544,"sortOrder":545},2289,"4.23",124,{"id":547,"label":548,"sortOrder":549},2290,"4.24",125,{"id":551,"label":552,"sortOrder":553},2291,"4.25",126,{"id":555,"label":556,"sortOrder":557},2292,"4.26",127,{"id":559,"label":560,"sortOrder":561},2293,"4.27",128,{"id":563,"label":564,"sortOrder":565},2294,"4.28",129,{"id":567,"label":568,"sortOrder":569},2295,"4.29",130,{"id":571,"label":572,"sortOrder":573},2296,"4.30",131,{"id":575,"label":576,"sortOrder":577},2297,"4.31",132,{"id":579,"label":580,"sortOrder":581},2298,"4.32",133,{"id":583,"label":584,"sortOrder":585},2299,"4.33",134,{"id":587,"label":588,"sortOrder":589},2300,"4.34",135,{"id":591,"label":592,"sortOrder":593},2301,"4.35",136,{"id":595,"label":596,"sortOrder":597},2302,"4.36",137,{"id":599,"label":600,"sortOrder":601},2303,"4.37",138,{"id":603,"label":604,"sortOrder":605},2304,"4.38",139,{"id":607,"label":608,"sortOrder":609},2305,"4.39",140,{"id":611,"label":612,"sortOrder":613},2306,"4.40",141,{"id":615,"label":616,"sortOrder":617},2307,"5.01",142,{"id":619,"label":620,"sortOrder":621},2308,"5.02",143,{"id":623,"label":624,"sortOrder":625},2309,"5.03",144,{"id":627,"label":628,"sortOrder":629},2310,"5.04",145,{"id":631,"label":632,"sortOrder":633},2311,"5.05",146,{"id":635,"label":636,"sortOrder":637},2312,"5.06",147,{"id":639,"label":640,"sortOrder":641},2313,"5.07",148,{"id":643,"label":644,"sortOrder":645},2314,"5.08",149,{"id":647,"label":648,"sortOrder":649},2315,"5.09",150,{"id":651,"label":652,"sortOrder":653},2316,"5.10",151,{"id":655,"label":656,"sortOrder":657},2317,"5.11",152,{"id":659,"label":660,"sortOrder":661},2318,"5.12",153,{"id":663,"label":664,"sortOrder":665},2319,"5.13",154,{"id":667,"label":668,"sortOrder":669},2320,"5.14",155,{"id":671,"label":672,"sortOrder":673},2321,"5.15",156,{"id":675,"label":676,"sortOrder":677},2322,"5.16",157,{"id":679,"label":680,"sortOrder":681},2323,"5.17",158,{"id":683,"label":684,"sortOrder":685},2324,"5.18",159,{"id":687,"label":688,"sortOrder":689},2325,"5.19",160,{"id":691,"label":692,"sortOrder":693},2326,"5.20",161,{"id":695,"label":696,"sortOrder":697},2327,"5.21",162,{"id":699,"label":700,"sortOrder":701},2328,"5.22",163,{"id":703,"label":704,"sortOrder":705},2329,"5.23",164,{"id":707,"label":708,"sortOrder":709},2330,"5.24",165,{"id":711,"label":712,"sortOrder":713},2331,"5.25",166,{"id":715,"label":716,"sortOrder":717},2332,"6.01",167,{"id":719,"label":720,"sortOrder":721},2333,"6.02",168,{"id":723,"label":724,"sortOrder":725},2334,"6.03",169,{"id":727,"label":728,"sortOrder":729},2335,"6.04",170,{"id":731,"label":732,"sortOrder":733},2336,"6.05",171,{"id":735,"label":736,"sortOrder":737},2337,"6.06",172,{"id":739,"label":740,"sortOrder":741},2338,"6.07",173,{"id":743,"label":744,"sortOrder":745},2339,"6.08",174,{"id":747,"label":748,"sortOrder":749},2340,"6.09",175,{"id":751,"label":752,"sortOrder":753},2341,"6.10",176,{"id":755,"label":756,"sortOrder":757},2342,"6.11",177,{"id":759,"label":760,"sortOrder":761},2343,"6.12",178,{"id":763,"label":764,"sortOrder":765},2344,"6.13",179,{"id":767,"label":768,"sortOrder":769},2345,"6.14",180,{"id":771,"label":772,"sortOrder":773},2346,"6.15",181,{"id":775,"label":776,"sortOrder":777},2347,"6.16",182,{"id":779,"label":780,"sortOrder":781},2348,"6.17",183,{"id":783,"label":784,"sortOrder":785},2349,"6.18",184,{"id":787,"label":788,"sortOrder":789},2350,"6.19",185,{"id":791,"label":792,"sortOrder":793},2351,"6.20",186,{"id":795,"label":796,"sortOrder":797},2352,"6.21",187,{"id":799,"label":800,"sortOrder":801},2353,"6.22",188,{"id":803,"label":804,"sortOrder":805},2354,"6.23",189,{"id":807,"label":808,"sortOrder":809},2355,"6.24",190,{"id":811,"label":812,"sortOrder":813},2356,"6.25",191,{"id":815,"label":816,"sortOrder":817},2357,"6.26",192,{"id":819,"label":820,"sortOrder":821},2358,"6.27",193,{"id":823,"label":824,"sortOrder":825},2359,"6.28",194,{"id":827,"label":828,"sortOrder":15},2360,"6.29",{"id":830,"label":831,"sortOrder":65},2361,"6.30",{"id":833,"label":834,"sortOrder":61},2362,"6.31",{"id":836,"label":837,"sortOrder":57},2363,"6.32",{"id":839,"label":840,"sortOrder":20},2364,"6.33",{"id":842,"label":843,"sortOrder":44},2365,"6.34",{"id":845,"label":846,"sortOrder":25},2366,"6.35",{"id":848,"label":849,"sortOrder":52},2367,"6.36",{"id":851,"label":852,"sortOrder":48},2368,"6.37",{"id":854,"label":855,"sortOrder":36},2369,"6.38",{"id":857,"label":858,"sortOrder":32},2370,"6.39",{"id":860,"label":861,"sortOrder":40},2371,"6.40",{"id":863,"label":864,"sortOrder":865},2372,"6.41",207,{"id":867,"label":868,"sortOrder":4},2373,"6.42",{"id":870,"label":871,"sortOrder":872},2374,"6.43",209,{"id":874,"label":875,"sortOrder":77},2375,"7.01",{"id":877,"label":878,"sortOrder":879},2376,"7.02",211,{"id":881,"label":882,"sortOrder":883},2377,"7.03",212,{"id":885,"label":886,"sortOrder":87},2378,"7.04",{"id":888,"label":889,"sortOrder":97},2379,"7.05",{"id":891,"label":892,"sortOrder":893},2380,"7.06",215,{"id":895,"label":896,"sortOrder":897},2381,"7.07",216,{"id":899,"label":900,"sortOrder":901},2382,"7.08",217,{"id":903,"label":904,"sortOrder":905},2383,"7.09",218,{"id":907,"label":908,"sortOrder":909},2384,"7.10",219,{"id":911,"label":912,"sortOrder":913},2385,"7.11",220,{"id":915,"label":916,"sortOrder":917},2386,"7.12",221,{"id":919,"label":920,"sortOrder":921},2387,"7.13",222,{"id":923,"label":924,"sortOrder":925},2388,"7.14",223,{"id":927,"label":928,"sortOrder":929},2389,"7.15",224,{"id":931,"label":932,"sortOrder":933},2390,"7.16",225,{"id":935,"label":936,"sortOrder":937},2391,"7.17",226,{"id":939,"label":940,"sortOrder":941},2392,"7.18",227,{"id":943,"label":944,"sortOrder":945},2393,"7.19",228,{"id":947,"label":948,"sortOrder":949},2394,"7.20",229,{"id":951,"label":952,"sortOrder":953},2395,"7.21",230,{"id":955,"label":956,"sortOrder":957},2396,"7.22",231,{"id":959,"label":960,"sortOrder":961},2397,"7.23",232,{"id":963,"label":964,"sortOrder":965},2398,"7.24",233,{"id":967,"label":968,"sortOrder":969},2399,"7.25",234,{"id":971,"label":972,"sortOrder":973},2400,"7.26",235,{"id":975,"label":976,"sortOrder":977},2401,"7.27",236,{"id":979,"label":980,"sortOrder":981},2402,"7.28",237,{"id":983,"label":984,"sortOrder":985},2403,"7.29",238,{"id":987,"label":988,"sortOrder":989},2404,"7.30",239,{"id":991,"label":992,"sortOrder":993},2405,"7.31",240,{"id":995,"label":996,"sortOrder":997},2406,"7.32",241,{"id":999,"sectionId":611,"editionId":70,"sectionLabel":612,"sectionSortOrder":613,"content":1000,"contentFormat":1001,"notes":1002,"title":74},17906,"\u003Cp>You may take the same answer to the question as to whether we\nought in all cases to show gratitude for kindness, and whether a\nbenefit ought in all cases to be repaid. It is my duty to show a\ngrateful mind, but in some cases my own poverty, in others the\nprosperity of the friend to whom I owe some return, will not permit\nme to give it. What, for instance, am I, a poor man, to give to a\nking or a rich man in return for his kindness, especially as some\nmen regard it as a wrong to have their benefits repaid, and are\nwont to pile one benefit upon another? In dealing with such\npersons, what more can I do than wish to repay them? Yet I ought\nnot to refuse to receive a new benefit, because I have not repaid\nthe former one. I shall take it as freely as it is given, and will\noffer myself to my friend as a wide field for the exercise of his\ngood nature: he who is unwilling to receive new benefits must be\ndissatisfied with what he has already received. Do you say, \"I\nshall not be able to return them?\" What is that to the purpose? I\nam willing enough to do so if opportunity or means were given me.\nHe gave it to me, of course, having both opportunity and means: is\nhe a good man or a bad one? if he is a good man, I have a good case\nagainst him, and I will not plead if he be a bad one. Neither do I\nthink it right to insist on making repayment, even though it be\nagainst the will of those whom we repay, and to press it upon them\nhowever reluctant they may be; it is not repayment to force an\nunwilling man to resume what you were once willing to take. Some\npeople, if any trifling present be sent to them, afterwards send\nback something else for no particular reason, and then declare that\nthey are under no obligation; to send something back at once, and\nbalance one present by another, is the next thing to refusing to\nreceive it. On some occasions I shall not return a benefit, even\nthough I be able to do so. When? When by so doing I shall myself\nlose more than he will gain, or if he would not notice any\nadvantage to himself in receiving that which it would be a great\nloss to me to return. The man who is always eager to repay under\nall circumstances, has not the feeling of a grateful man, but of a\ndebtor; and, to put it shortly, he who is too eager to repay, is\nunwilling to be in his friend's debt; he who is unwilling, and yet\nis in his friend's debt, is ungrateful.\n\u003C/p>\n","html",[1003,1005],{"id":23,"content":1004},"See Seneca on \"Clemency,\" book i., ch. ix.",{"id":55,"content":1006},"Gertz, \"Stud. Crit,\" p. 159, note.",[],1785969063086]