[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":451},["ShallowReactive",2],{"stoic-topic-desire-and-self-control-llm_tag-all-relevance":3},{"id":4,"slug":5,"name":6,"shortDescription":7,"intro":8,"synthesis":9,"method":10,"runId":11,"passages":12},34,"desire-and-self-control","Desire & Self-Control","Craving, appetite, and bodily pleasure, and the discipline of restraining them. Wanting less, resisting indulgence, and mastering impulse.","Desire, on the Stoic account, is where you hand your peace of mind to something outside you. Wanting a thing that is not up to you means the world now decides how you feel, and it will not consult you. The discipline is to want less, and to want the right kind of thing.\n\nThis is not asceticism for its own sake. The complaint in these passages is not that pleasure is wicked but that appetite has no natural stopping point: once you go past what you actually need, as Epictetus puts it, there is no limit.","Epictetus treated the training of desire as the first of his three disciplines, the one to get right before the others are worth attempting. Musonius Rufus went at it concretely, down to arguments about what to eat. Seneca, characteristically, is more interested in the pathology - the cultivated craving, the vice that has been pampered until there is no strength left in the person.\n\nThe practical suggestion running through them is simpler than the theory: shrink the number of things whose absence would trouble you, and you have made yourself harder to reach.","llm_tag",15,[13,29,44,52,67,75,86,97,105,113,121,129,139,147,158,166,174,182,190,198,206,214,222,230,238,247,255,263,271,281,292,300,308,316,324,332,340,348,356,364,372,380,387,395,403,411,419,427,435,443],{"sectionId":14,"sectionLabel":15,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":18,"relevanceNote":19,"work":20,"author":24,"readingUrl":28},1127,"47",5,"llm_1_5","When you have become adjusted to simple living in regard to your bodily wants, do not preen yourself about the accomplishment; and so likewise, if you are a water-drinker, do not on every occasion say that you are a water-drinker.","Centrally about restraining bodily appetites, simple living, and mastering physical cravings without ostentation.",{"id":21,"name":22,"urlSlug":23},1,"The Enchiridion","enchiridion",{"id":25,"name":26,"shortName":26,"urlSlug":27},218,"Epictetus","epictetus","/epictetus/enchiridion/47",{"sectionId":30,"sectionLabel":31,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":32,"relevanceNote":33,"work":34,"author":38,"readingUrl":43},2395,"7.21","Upon this our philosopher not unwillingly carried his three or four denarii home again, shaking them every now and then; afterwards, blaming himself for the pleasure which he had secretly felt at not paying his debt, and perceiving that he enjoyed having made this trifling gain, he returned to the shop, and saying, \"the man lives for you, pay him what you owe,\" he passed four denarii into the shop through the crack of the closed door, and let them fall inside, punishing himself for his unconscionable greediness that he might not form the habit of appropriating that which is not his own.","The entire passage is about resisting the temptation to keep money not owed, mastering the appetite for gain, and disciplining impulse through self-punishment.",{"id":35,"name":36,"urlSlug":37},195,"On Benefits","on-benefits",{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},208,"Lucius Annaeus Seneca the Younger","Seneca","seneca","/seneca/on-benefits/7.21",{"sectionId":45,"sectionLabel":46,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":47,"relevanceNote":48,"work":49,"author":50,"readingUrl":51},1119,"39","For once you go beyond the measure there is no limit.","Centrally about restraining desire and appetite: the body's needs set a natural measure, and excess desire for luxuries (gilded, purple, embroidered shoes) leads to ruin.",{"id":21,"name":22,"urlSlug":23},{"id":25,"name":26,"shortName":26,"urlSlug":27},"/epictetus/enchiridion/39",{"sectionId":53,"sectionLabel":54,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":55,"relevanceNote":56,"work":57,"author":61,"readingUrl":66},913,"9.01","Moreover, he who runs after pleasures as goods and away from pains as evils commits sin; for being such a man he must necessarily often blame Universal Nature for distributing to bad and good contrary to their desert, because the bad are often employed in pleasures and acquire what may produce these, while the good are involved in pain and in what may produce this.","Explicitly condemns running after pleasures and away from pains as goods and evils, directly addressing the craving and indulgence that must be mastered.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},2,"The Meditations","meditations",{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},217,"Marcus Aurelius Antoninus","Marcus Aurelius","aurelius","/aurelius/meditations/9.01",{"sectionId":68,"sectionLabel":69,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":70,"relevanceNote":71,"work":72,"author":73,"readingUrl":74},1024,"11.19","The fourth thing that will cause you to reproach yourself is that this ensues from your more divine part being overcome and yielding to the less honourable and mortal portion, the body and its gross pleasures.","Directly addresses mastering bodily appetites and gross pleasures; the struggle against indulgence of the body over the rational part.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/11.19",{"sectionId":76,"sectionLabel":77,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":78,"relevanceNote":79,"work":80,"author":84,"readingUrl":85},2625,"1.16","Yet the very time which they enjoy is brief and soon past, and is made much briefer by their own fault: for they run from one pleasure to another, and are not able to devote themselves consistently to one passion: their days are not long, but odious to them: on the other hand, how short they find the nights which they spend with courtesans or over wine?","Explicitly treats craving and indulgence—running from one pleasure to another, inability to restrain appetite, and the enslavement to passions.",{"id":81,"name":82,"urlSlug":83},202,"On the Shortness of Life","on-the-shortness-of-life",{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-the-shortness-of-life/1.16",{"sectionId":87,"sectionLabel":88,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":89,"relevanceNote":90,"work":91,"author":95,"readingUrl":96},2557,"XII","The pleasures of wise men, on the other hand, are mild, decorous, verging on dullness, kept under restraint and scarcely noticeable, and are neither invited to come nor received with honour when they come of their own accord, nor are they welcomed with any delight by those whom they visit, who mix them up with their lives and fill up empty spaces with them, like an amusing farce in the intervals of serious business.","Explicitly about restraining pleasure, the difference between indulgent excess and temperate desire in wise men.",{"id":92,"name":93,"urlSlug":94},199,"On the Happy Life","on-the-happy-life",{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-the-happy-life/XII",{"sectionId":98,"sectionLabel":99,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":100,"relevanceNote":101,"work":102,"author":103,"readingUrl":104},961,"10.01","Wilt thou one day be filled and without want, craving nothing and desiring nothing, animate or inanimate, for indulgence in pleasures; not time wherein longer to indulge thyself, nor happy situation of place or room or breezes nor harmony of men?","The passage explicitly addresses restraining cravings and desire for pleasures, indulgence, and external things.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/10.01",{"sectionId":106,"sectionLabel":107,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":108,"relevanceNote":109,"work":110,"author":111,"readingUrl":112},2555,"X","\"Yet when moderation lessens pleasure, it impairs the highest good.\" You devote yourself to pleasures, I check them; you indulge in pleasure, I use it; you think that it is the highest good, I do not even think it to be good: for the sake of pleasure I do nothing, you do everything.","The entire passage debates pleasure, indulgence, and the discipline of moderation—restraining appetite rather than surrendering to it.",{"id":92,"name":93,"urlSlug":94},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-the-happy-life/X",{"sectionId":114,"sectionLabel":115,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":116,"relevanceNote":117,"work":118,"author":119,"readingUrl":120},2559,"XIV","On the contrary, those who have permitted pleasure to lead the van, have neither one nor the other: for they lose virtue altogether, and yet they do not possess pleasure, but are possessed by it, and are either tortured by its absence or choked by its excess, being wretched if deserted by it, and yet more wretched if overwhelmed by it, like those who are caught in the shoals of the Syrtes and at one time are left on dry ground and at another tossed on the flowing waves.","Explicitly addresses the discipline of restraining bodily pleasure, the loss of self-control, and being possessed by appetite rather than mastering it.",{"id":92,"name":93,"urlSlug":94},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-the-happy-life/XIV",{"sectionId":122,"sectionLabel":123,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":124,"relevanceNote":125,"work":126,"author":127,"readingUrl":128},2280,"4.14","I should not call a woman modest, if she rebuffed her lover in order to increase his passion, or because she feared the law or her husband; as Ovid says: \"She that denies, because she does not dare To yield, in spirit grants her lover's prayer.\" Indeed, the woman who owes her chastity, not to her own virtue, but to fear, may rightly be classed as a sinner.","Central concern with restraining base motives (lust, fear-driven compliance) and mastering selfish impulses in favour of genuine virtue.",{"id":35,"name":36,"urlSlug":37},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-benefits/4.14",{"sectionId":130,"sectionLabel":131,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":132,"relevanceNote":133,"work":134,"author":137,"readingUrl":138},2836,"112","Now this person, concerning whom you have sent me your message in writing, has no strength; for he has pampered his vices.","The central theme is the enslaving power of indulged desires (luxury, vices, pampering) and the difficulty of restraining them once habits are formed.",{"id":39,"name":135,"urlSlug":136},"Moral Letters to Lucilius","letters",{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/letters/112",{"sectionId":140,"sectionLabel":141,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":142,"relevanceNote":143,"work":144,"author":145,"readingUrl":146},1121,"41","It is a mark of an ungifted man to spend a great deal of time in what concerns his body, as in much exercise, much eating, much drinking, much evacuating of the bowels, much copulating.","Directly addresses excessive bodily appetites and the need to restrain indulgence in eating, drinking, exercise, and copulating.",{"id":21,"name":22,"urlSlug":23},{"id":25,"name":26,"shortName":26,"urlSlug":27},"/epictetus/enchiridion/41",{"sectionId":148,"sectionLabel":149,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":150,"relevanceNote":151,"work":152,"author":156,"readingUrl":157},2441,"2.08","They hate the fortunate and despise the unfortunate: they grudgingly endure the great, and oppress the small: they are fired by diverse lusts: they would wreck everything for the sake of a little pleasure or plunder: they live as though they were in a school of gladiators, fighting with the same people with whom they live: it is like a society of wild beasts, save that beasts are tame with one another, and refrain from biting their own species, whereas men tear one another, and gorge themselves upon one another.","The passage explicitly condemns uncontrolled desires, lustful appetites, and the pursuit of pleasure and plunder as defining vices of society.",{"id":153,"name":154,"urlSlug":155},197,"On Anger","on-anger",{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-anger/2.08",{"sectionId":159,"sectionLabel":160,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":161,"relevanceNote":162,"work":163,"author":164,"readingUrl":165},1128,"48","He has put away from himself his every desire, and has transferred his aversion to those things only, of what is under our control, which are contrary to nature.","Directly describes putting away desire and transferring aversion to align only with what is in our control and natural.",{"id":21,"name":22,"urlSlug":23},{"id":25,"name":26,"shortName":26,"urlSlug":27},"/epictetus/enchiridion/48",{"sectionId":167,"sectionLabel":168,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":169,"relevanceNote":170,"work":171,"author":172,"readingUrl":173},599,"2.10","For clearly one who loses his temper is turning away from Reason with a kind of pain and inward spasm; whereas he who offends through appetite is the victim of pleasure and is clearly more vicious in a way and more effeminate in his wrong-doing.","The passage is centrally about appetite as a vice, contrasting errors of appetite with errors of temper, and explicitly condemns appetite-driven wrongdoing as particularly effeminate and vicious.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/2.10",{"sectionId":175,"sectionLabel":176,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":177,"relevanceNote":178,"work":179,"author":180,"readingUrl":181},2437,"2.04","The next is combined with a wish, though not an obstinate one, as, for example, \"It is my duty to avenge myself, because I have been injured,\" or \"It is right that this man should be punished, because he has committed a crime.\" The third emotion is already beyond our control, because it overrides reason, and wishes to avenge itself, not if it be its duty, but whether or no.","Centrally about the stages of passion—wishes combined with judgment, and the struggle between impulse and reason to control emotion.",{"id":153,"name":154,"urlSlug":155},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-anger/2.04",{"sectionId":183,"sectionLabel":184,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":185,"relevanceNote":186,"work":187,"author":188,"readingUrl":189},1114,"34","However, if you feel that a suitable occasion has arisen to do the deed, be careful not to allow its enticement, and sweetness, and attractiveness to overcome you; but set over against all this the thought, how much better is the consciousness of having won a victory over it.","The passage is explicitly about resisting the enticement of pleasure, restraining appetite, and winning victory over bodily desire through discipline.",{"id":21,"name":22,"urlSlug":23},{"id":25,"name":26,"shortName":26,"urlSlug":27},"/epictetus/enchiridion/34",{"sectionId":191,"sectionLabel":192,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":193,"relevanceNote":194,"work":195,"author":196,"readingUrl":197},2422,"1.10","The mind can find no safe repose there, it must needs be shaken and tempest-tossed if it be safe only because of its own defects, if it cannot be brave without anger, diligent without greed, quiet without fear: such is the despotism under which a man must live if he becomes the slave of a passion.","Explicitly discusses mastering impulses and passions, and the discipline required to restrain desire and irrational drives rather than be enslaved by them.",{"id":153,"name":154,"urlSlug":155},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-anger/1.10",{"sectionId":199,"sectionLabel":200,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":201,"relevanceNote":202,"work":203,"author":204,"readingUrl":205},2784,"60","It is not the natural hunger of our bellies that costs us dear, but our solicitous cravings.","The passage is centrally about restraining appetite and solicitous cravings, distinguishing natural hunger from excessive desire and the discipline needed to master impulse.",{"id":39,"name":135,"urlSlug":136},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/letters/60",{"sectionId":207,"sectionLabel":208,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":209,"relevanceNote":210,"work":211,"author":212,"readingUrl":213},2220,"2.27","His greed ever stretches itself out further, and he does not understand the greatness of his success because he always looks forward to the point at which he aims, and never back towards that from which he started.","Directly addresses unchecked craving and the failure to restrain appetite; greed and ambition presented as unmastered impulses.",{"id":35,"name":36,"urlSlug":37},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-benefits/2.27",{"sectionId":215,"sectionLabel":216,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":217,"relevanceNote":218,"work":219,"author":220,"readingUrl":221},956,"9.40","But if they are powerful, why not rather pray them for the gift to fear none of these things, to desire none of them, to sorrow for none of them, rather than that any one of them should be present or absent?","Explicitly prescribes requesting freedom from desire and fear; gives concrete examples of retraining desire through prayer.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/9.40",{"sectionId":223,"sectionLabel":224,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":225,"relevanceNote":226,"work":227,"author":228,"readingUrl":229},921,"9.07","Wipe out imagination: check impulse: quench desire: keep the governing self in its own control.","Directly commands 'quench desire' and the restraint of appetite as core discipline.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/9.07",{"sectionId":231,"sectionLabel":232,"score":16,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":233,"relevanceNote":234,"work":235,"author":236,"readingUrl":237},2550,"V","For no one can be styled happy who is beyond the influence of truth: and consequently a happy life is unchangeable, and is founded upon a true and trustworthy discernment; for the mind is uncontaminated and freed from all evils only when it is able to escape not merely from wounds but also from scratches, when it will always be able to maintain the position which it has taken up, and defend it even against the angry assaults of Fortune: for with regard to sensual pleasures, though they were to surround one on every side, and use every means of assault, trying to win over the mind by caresses and making trial of every conceivable stratagem to attract either our entire selves or our separate parts, yet what mortal that retains any traces of human origin would wish to be tickled day and night, and, neglecting his mind, to devote himself to bodily enjoyments?","Extensively discusses mastering sensual pleasures and bodily indulgence, arguing that a truly happy person resists the assaults of temptation.",{"id":92,"name":93,"urlSlug":94},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-the-happy-life/V",{"sectionId":239,"sectionLabel":240,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":242,"relevanceNote":243,"work":244,"author":245,"readingUrl":246},1101,"21",4,"Keep before your eyes day by day death and exile, and everything that seems terrible, but most of all death; and then you will never have any abject thought, nor will you yearn for anything beyond measure.","The passage explicitly aims to curb excessive desire ('you will never yearn for anything beyond measure'), using meditation on mortality as a tool of restraint.",{"id":21,"name":22,"urlSlug":23},{"id":25,"name":26,"shortName":26,"urlSlug":27},"/epictetus/enchiridion/21",{"sectionId":248,"sectionLabel":249,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":250,"relevanceNote":251,"work":252,"author":253,"readingUrl":254},1092,"12","Your paltry oil gets spilled, your miserable wine stolen; say to yourself, \"This is the price paid for a calm spirit, this the price for peace of mind.\" Nothing is got without a price.","Explicitly teaches restraint and acceptance of loss (spilled oil, stolen wine) as the price of mastering one's desires and maintaining peace of mind.",{"id":21,"name":22,"urlSlug":23},{"id":25,"name":26,"shortName":26,"urlSlug":27},"/epictetus/enchiridion/12",{"sectionId":256,"sectionLabel":257,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":258,"relevanceNote":259,"work":260,"author":261,"readingUrl":262},1088,"8","Do not seek to have everything that happens happen as you wish, but wish for everything to happen as it actually does happen, and your life will be serene.","Directly addresses the discipline of restraining desire (wishing for things to be other than they are) and mastering the impulse to want differently.",{"id":21,"name":22,"urlSlug":23},{"id":25,"name":26,"shortName":26,"urlSlug":27},"/epictetus/enchiridion/8",{"sectionId":264,"sectionLabel":265,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":266,"relevanceNote":267,"work":268,"author":269,"readingUrl":270},595,"2.06","Brief is the life of each of us, and this of yours is nearly ended, and yet you do not reverence yourself, but commit your well-being to the charge of other men's souls.","The passage directly addresses committing one's well-being to others' charge, a failure of self-control and proper discipline.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/2.06",{"sectionId":272,"sectionLabel":192,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":273,"relevanceNote":274,"work":275,"author":279,"readingUrl":280},2522,"We declare that Augustus was a good emperor, and that he was well worthy to bear his parent's name, for no other reason than because he did not even show cruelty in avenging personal insults, which most princes feel more keenly than actual injuries; because he smiled at scandalous jests against himself, because it was evident that he himself suffered when he punished others, because he was so far from putting to death even those whom he had convicted of intriguing with his daughter, that when they were banished he gave them passports to enable them to travel more safely.","Emphasizes restraint from indulgence in cruelty and revenge, mastering the impulse to punish personal insults and enemies—self-discipline in power.",{"id":276,"name":277,"urlSlug":278},198,"On Clemency","on-clemency",{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-clemency/1.10",{"sectionId":282,"sectionLabel":283,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":284,"relevanceNote":285,"work":286,"author":290,"readingUrl":291},2917,"3.11","1 Whoever thinks any other thing to be good except those things which depend on the will, let him envy, let him desire, let him flatter, let him be perturbed; whoever considers anything else to be evil, let him grieve, let him lament, let him weep, let him be unhappy.","Central concern: the passage condemns envy, desire, flattery, grief, and lamentation as symptoms of wrongly valuing externals, and prescribes disciplined judgment.",{"id":287,"name":288,"urlSlug":289},209,"Discourses","discourses",{"id":25,"name":26,"shortName":26,"urlSlug":27},"/epictetus/discourses/3.11",{"sectionId":293,"sectionLabel":294,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":295,"relevanceNote":296,"work":297,"author":298,"readingUrl":299},2370,"6.39","He prays aloud, \"May he fall into my power, may he need my influence, may not be able to be safe and respectable without my aid, may he be so unfortunate that whatever return I make to him may be regarded as a benefit.\" To the gods alone he adds, \"May domestic treasons encompass him, which can be quelled by me alone; may some powerful and virulent enemy, some excited and armed mob, assail him; may he be set upon by a creditor or an informer.\"","Explicitly about the ungoverned desire to dominate others and the selfish appetites that drive such wishes; mastery of these impulses is needed.",{"id":35,"name":36,"urlSlug":37},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-benefits/6.39",{"sectionId":301,"sectionLabel":302,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":303,"relevanceNote":304,"work":305,"author":306,"readingUrl":307},747,"6.30","Take heed not to be transformed into a Caesar, not to be dipped in the purple dye; for it does happen.","The opening warning against being 'transformed into a Caesar' and being 'dipped in the purple dye' directly addresses resisting the seductive pull of wealth, power, and ambition; the passage emphasizes restraint, simplicity, and disdain for glory.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/6.30",{"sectionId":309,"sectionLabel":310,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":311,"relevanceNote":312,"work":313,"author":314,"readingUrl":315},2363,"6.32","The late Emperor Augustus banished his daughter, whose conduct went beyond the shame of ordinary immodesty, and made public the scandals of the imperial house ***** ***** Led away by his passion, he divulged all these crimes which, as emperor, he ought to have kept secret with as much care as he punished them, because the shame of some deeds asperses even him who avenges them.","The central problem is Augustus being led by passion and unable to restrain his impulse to divulge secrets, showing failure of self-control.",{"id":35,"name":36,"urlSlug":37},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-benefits/6.32",{"sectionId":317,"sectionLabel":318,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":319,"relevanceNote":320,"work":321,"author":322,"readingUrl":323},863,"8.12","When you are called from sleep with difficulty, revive the thought that to render social acts is according to your constitution and to human nature, but to sleep is what you share also with dumb animals.","Waking from sleep against inclination requires disciplining the desire to remain at rest.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/8.12",{"sectionId":325,"sectionLabel":326,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":327,"relevanceNote":328,"work":329,"author":330,"readingUrl":331},859,"8.08","You are not able to read; but you are able to restrain your arrogance, you are able to rise above pleasures and pains, you are able to be superior to fame, you are able not only not to be angry with the unfeeling and graceless, but to care for them besides.","Rising above pleasures and pains, restraining arrogance, and resisting reactive anger all exemplify disciplined self-control over desire and impulse.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/8.08",{"sectionId":333,"sectionLabel":334,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":335,"relevanceNote":336,"work":337,"author":338,"readingUrl":339},1081,"1","With such high aims, therefore, remember that you must bestir yourself with no slight effort to lay hold of them, but you will have to give up some things entirely, and defer others for the time being.","The passage calls for giving up certain things and deferring others, teaching discipline of desire and the sacrifice of external goods for true freedom.",{"id":21,"name":22,"urlSlug":23},{"id":25,"name":26,"shortName":26,"urlSlug":27},"/epictetus/enchiridion/1",{"sectionId":341,"sectionLabel":342,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":343,"relevanceNote":344,"work":345,"author":346,"readingUrl":347},2286,"4.20","If a man is likely to meet with affronts by showing his gratitude, if he knows that far from gaining anything by it, he must lose much even of what he has already acquired, will he not cheerfully act to his own disadvantage?","Central theme: resisting base desires for gain and mastering the impulse toward selfish advantage.",{"id":35,"name":36,"urlSlug":37},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-benefits/4.20",{"sectionId":349,"sectionLabel":350,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":351,"relevanceNote":352,"work":353,"author":354,"readingUrl":355},880,"8.29","Wipe out impressions by continually saying to yourself: it is in my power now not to allow any wickedness to be in this soul of mine, any appetite or disturbance at all, but seeing what is the character of them all I employ each according to its worth.","Explicitly concerns mastering appetites and disturbances through disciplined restraint and evaluation.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/8.29",{"sectionId":357,"sectionLabel":358,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":359,"relevanceNote":360,"work":361,"author":362,"readingUrl":363},1116,"36","When, therefore, you are eating with another person, remember to regard, not merely the value for your body of what lies before you, but also to maintain your respect for your host.","Teaches restraint of appetite (taking less food) and mastering the impulse to indulge the body for the sake of social obligation.",{"id":21,"name":22,"urlSlug":23},{"id":25,"name":26,"shortName":26,"urlSlug":27},"/epictetus/enchiridion/36",{"sectionId":365,"sectionLabel":366,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":367,"relevanceNote":368,"work":369,"author":370,"readingUrl":371},904,"8.53","Do you wish to please a man who doesn't please himself?","Implicitly critiques the lack of self-mastery and discipline in a man who does not please himself.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/8.53",{"sectionId":373,"sectionLabel":374,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":375,"relevanceNote":376,"work":377,"author":378,"readingUrl":379},569,"1.03","From my mother: piety and bountifulness, to keep myself not only from doing evil but even from dwelling on evil thoughts, simplicity too in diet and to be far removed from the ways of the rich.","Explicitly about restraining desire and impulse: abstaining from evil, avoiding rich indulgence, maintaining simplicity in diet",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/1.03",{"sectionId":381,"sectionLabel":192,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":382,"relevanceNote":383,"work":384,"author":385,"readingUrl":386},576,"From Alexander the grammarian: to avoid fault-finding and not to censure in a carping spirit any who employ an exotic phrase, a solecism, or harsh expression, but oneself to use, neatly and precisely, the correct phrase, by way of answer or confirmation or handling of the actual question—the thing, not its verbal expression—or by some other equally happy reminder.","Directly teaches restraint of the impulse to criticize and the discipline of responding constructively; mastering the urge to carp and fault-find.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/1.10",{"sectionId":388,"sectionLabel":389,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":390,"relevanceNote":391,"work":392,"author":393,"readingUrl":394},2785,"61","Let us cease to desire that which we have been desiring.","Explicitly about ceasing desire and restraining craving; central to the passage's opening and throughout.",{"id":39,"name":135,"urlSlug":136},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/letters/61",{"sectionId":396,"sectionLabel":397,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":398,"relevanceNote":399,"work":400,"author":401,"readingUrl":402},2377,"7.03","We need not wonder at this, for whatever is obtained by covetousness is simply swallowed up and lost, nor does it matter how much is poured into its insatiable maw.","The passage treats covetousness as an insatiable appetite that cannot be satisfied through indulgence, contrasting it with wise restraint and freedom from craving.",{"id":35,"name":36,"urlSlug":37},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-benefits/7.03",{"sectionId":404,"sectionLabel":405,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":406,"relevanceNote":407,"work":408,"author":409,"readingUrl":410},2487,"3.18","Why do I pry into ancient history? quite lately Gaius Caesar flogged and tortured Sextus Papinius, whose father was a consular, Betilienas Bassus, his own quaestor, and several others, both senators and knights, on the same day, not to carry out any judicial inquiry, but merely to amuse himself.","Centerpiece of passage: Caesar's unrestrained cruelty and monstrous desires, indulgence in torturing others for mere amusement without self-control.",{"id":153,"name":154,"urlSlug":155},{"id":39,"name":40,"shortName":41,"urlSlug":42},"/seneca/on-anger/3.18",{"sectionId":412,"sectionLabel":413,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":414,"relevanceNote":415,"work":416,"author":417,"readingUrl":418},1029,"11.24","The Spartans used to put seats for visitors at their entertainments in the shade, and to seat themselves wherever they found room.","Demonstrates mastery over bodily comfort and appetites through indifference to seating arrangements.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/11.24",{"sectionId":420,"sectionLabel":421,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":422,"relevanceNote":423,"work":424,"author":425,"readingUrl":426},594,"2.05","And so you will, if only you do each act as though it were your last, freed from every random aim, from wilful turning away from the directing Reason, from pretence, self-love and displeasure with what is allotted to you.","Emphasizes freedom from wilful turning away and self-love, and mastering desires to live rightly.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/2.05",{"sectionId":428,"sectionLabel":429,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":430,"relevanceNote":431,"work":432,"author":433,"readingUrl":434},680,"5.01","Is it for this that I am fashioned, to lie in bedclothes and keep myself warm?' 'But this is more pleasant.' 'Were you born then to please yourself; in fact for feeling, not for action?","Directly addresses the temptation of pleasant sensation and comfort, arguing against self-indulgence and for restraint of bodily pleasure.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/5.01",{"sectionId":436,"sectionLabel":437,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":438,"relevanceNote":439,"work":440,"author":441,"readingUrl":442},712,"5.31","How many beautiful things have been revealed, how many pleasures and pains you have looked down upon, how many ambitions ignored, to how many unkind persons you have been kind!","Sentence 3 explicitly celebrates looking down upon pleasures and pains and ignoring ambitions—mastery over desire and appetite.",{"id":58,"name":59,"urlSlug":60},{"id":62,"name":63,"shortName":64,"urlSlug":65},"/aurelius/meditations/5.31",{"sectionId":444,"sectionLabel":445,"score":241,"scoreScale":17,"pullQuote":446,"relevanceNote":447,"work":448,"author":449,"readingUrl":450},1090,"10","If you see a handsome lad or woman, you will find continence the faculty to employ here; if hard labour is laid upon you, you will find endurance; if reviling, you will find patience to bear evil.","Continence and restraint of bodily appetite are explicitly named as faculties to deploy when encountering attractive persons or hardship.",{"id":21,"name":22,"urlSlug":23},{"id":25,"name":26,"shortName":26,"urlSlug":27},"/epictetus/enchiridion/10",1785969084097]