← All topics

Practice & Progress

The Stoics treated philosophy as training rather than doctrine - something closer to what an athlete does than what a scholar knows. Knowing the arguments is the easy part and, on their view, worth very little on its own. The question is whether the principles are available to you at the moment something goes wrong. Hence the exercises: the evening review of the day's conduct, the rehearsal of principles until they are ready to hand, the willingness to attempt what you expect to be bad at.

50 passages

"From Rusticus: to get an impression of need for reform and treatment of character; not to run off into zeal for rhetoric, writing on speculative themes, discoursing on edifying texts, exhibiting in fanciful colours the ascetic or the philanthropist."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 1.07

"On no occasion call yourself a philosopher, and do not, for the most part, talk among laymen about your philosophic principles, but do what follows from your principles."

— Epictetus, The Enchiridion 46

"Of course we must sometimes also make use of these harangues, if I may so call them, when a doubting member needs to be spurred on; but when the aim is to make a man learn, and not merely to make him wish to learn, we must have recourse to the low-toned words of conversation."

— Seneca, Moral Letters to Lucilius 38

"Is then the fruit of a fig-tree not perfected suddenly and in one hour, and would you possess the fruit of a man’s mind in so short a time and so easily?"

— Epictetus, Discourses 1.15

"This is much more true of living."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 11.29

"Practise even the things which you despair of achieving."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 12.06

"Don't be disgusted, don't give up, don't be impatient if you do not carry out entirely conduct based in every detail upon right principles; but after a fall return again, and rejoice if most of your actions are worthier of human character."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 5.09

"And with you it lies to rekindle them constantly."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 7.02

"As we exercise ourselves against sophistical questions, so we ought to exercise ourselves daily against appearances; for these appearances also propose questions to us."

— Epictetus, Discourses 3.8

"But we do the opposite; for we spend our time in the third division, and all our zeal is devoted to it, while we utterly neglect the first."

— Epictetus, The Enchiridion 52

"Every day those sacred doctrines of yours, whichever of them you imagine and admit without scientific investigation, will be obliterated, whereas you should look at every object and do every act so that, at one and the same time, circumstance is accomplished and theory exercised, and the confidence which comes from a scientific knowledge of each experience is preserved, unnoticed, not concealed."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 10.09

"Wipe away the impress of imagination."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 7.29

"If you are now neglectful and easy-going, and always making one delay after another, and fixing first one day and then another, after which you will pay attention to yourself, then without realizing it you will make no progress, but, living and dying, will continue to be a layman throughout."

— Epictetus, The Enchiridion 51

"The spirit ought to be brought up for examination daily."

— Seneca, On Anger 3.36

"In the use of principles model yourself on the boxer, not the gladiator."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 12.09

"Don't any more discuss at large what the good man is like, but be good."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 10.16

"Wipe out impressions by continually saying to yourself: it is in my power now not to allow any wickedness to be in this soul of mine, any appetite or disturbance at all, but seeing what is the character of them all I employ each according to its worth."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 8.29

"Don't hope for Plato's Utopia, but be content to make a very small step forward and reflect that the result even of this is no trifle."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 9.29

"If you yearn for philosophy, prepare at once to be met with ridicule, to have many people jeer at you, and say, "Here he is again, turned philosopher all of a sudden," and "Where do you suppose he got that high brow?" But do you not put on a high brow, and do you so hold fast to the things which to you seem best, as a man who has been assigned by God to this post; and remember that if you abide by the same principles, those who formerly used to laugh at you will later come to admire you, but if you are worsted by them, you will get the laugh on yourself twice."

— Epictetus, The Enchiridion 22

"If he, who through constant abuse had forgotten how to blush, could do this by sheer brazenness, why should not he who has made some progress in the education of a gentleman and the study of philosophy?"

— Seneca, On the Firmness of a Wise Man 1.17

"And if ever you want to train to develop physical endurance, do it by yourself and not for outsiders to behold; do not throw your arms around statues, 24 but on occasion, when you are very thirsty, take cold water into your mouth, and then spit it out, without telling anybody."

— Epictetus, The Enchiridion 47

"I shall divide what I am about to say into two parts: first, that a man may from the very beginning of his life give himself up entirely to the contemplation of truth; secondly, that a man when he has already completed his term of service, has the best of rights, that of his shattered health, to do this, and that he may then apply his mind to other studies after the manner of the Vestal virgins, who allot different duties to different years, first learn how to perform the sacred rites, and when they have learned them teach others."

— Seneca, On Leisure 1.02

"Upon this our philosopher not unwillingly carried his three or four denarii home again, shaking them every now and then; afterwards, blaming himself for the pleasure which he had secretly felt at not paying his debt, and perceiving that he enjoyed having made this trifling gain, he returned to the shop, and saying, "the man lives for you, pay him what you owe," he passed four denarii into the shop through the crack of the closed door, and let them fall inside, punishing himself for his unconscionable greediness that he might not form the habit of appropriating that which is not his own."

— Seneca, On Benefits 7.21

"For this reason Socrates also trusting to this power used to say, I am used to call no other witness of what I say, but I am always satisfied with him with whom I am discussing, and I ask him to give his opinion and call him as a witness, and though he is only one, he is sufficient in the place of all."

— Epictetus, Discourses 2.26

"When you run against some one's wrong behaviour, go on at once to reflect what similar wrong act of your own there is; for instance, to esteem money or pleasure or glory as goods, and so on with each kind."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 10.30

"Then go in to the great personage boldly and remember these things; and you will see what a youth is who has studied these things when he is among men who have not studied them."

— Epictetus, Discourses 1.30

"However, since it is necessary, whatever you do, that your thoughts should sometimes revert to me, and that I should now be present to your mind more often than your other children, not because they are less dear to you, but because it is natural to lay one's hands more often upon a place that pains one; learn how you are to think of me: I am as joyous and cheerful as in my best days: indeed these days are my best, because my mind is relieved from all pressure of business and is at leisure to attend to its own affairs, and at one time amuses itself with lighter studies, at another eagerly presses its inquiries into its own nature and that of the universe: first it considers the countries of the world and their position: then the character of the sea which flows between them, and the alternate ebbings and flowings of its tides; next it investigates all the terrors which hang between heaven and earth, the region which is torn asunder by thunderings, lightnings, gusts of wind, vapour, showers of snow and hail."

— Seneca, On Consolation - To Helvia 1.20

"Let your impulse be to see always and entirely what precisely it is which is creating an impression in your imagination, and to open it up by dividing it into cause, matter, relation, and into the period within which it will be bound to have ceased."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 12.17

"You should adopt this practice all through your life, and where things make an impression which is very plausible, uncover their nakedness, see into their cheapness, strip off the profession on which they vaunt themselves."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 6.13

"It is useful for a man to understand his disease, and to break its strength before it becomes developed."

— Seneca, On Anger 3.10

"But all these precautions must be adopted without affectation."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 7.60

"Besides this, there is a large part of mankind which might return to virtue if the hope of pardon were not denied them."

— Seneca, On Clemency 1.02

"Just as those tools which are kept in use, and are daily touched by the hand, are never in danger of growing rusty, while those which are not brought before our eyes, and lie as if superfluous, not being required for common use, collect dirt by the mere lapse of time, so likewise that which our thoughts frequently turn over and renew never passes from our memory, which only loses those things to which it seldom directs its eyes."

— Seneca, On Benefits 3.02

"THERE are some things, my most excellent Liberalis, which lie completely outside of our actual life, and which we only inquire into in order to exercise our intellects, while others both give us pleasure while we are discovering them, and are of use when discovered."

— Seneca, On Benefits 6.01

"From Diognetus: to avoid idle enthusiasms; to disbelieve the professions of sorcerers and impostors about incantations and exorcism of spirits and the like; not to cock-fight or to be excited about such sports; to put up with plain-speaking and to become familiar with philosophy; to hear the lectures first of Baccheius, then of Tandasis and Marcian, in boyhood to write essays and to aspire to the camp-bed and skin coverlet and the other things which are part of the Greek training."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 1.06

"But he has been taken in a very hardened state, or rather (and this is a more difficult problem), in a very soft state, broken down by bad and inveterate habits."

— Seneca, Moral Letters to Lucilius 112

"Education ought to be carried on with the greatest and most salutary assiduity: for it is easy to mould minds while they are still tender, but it is difficult to uproot vices which have grown up with ourselves."

— Seneca, On Anger 2.18

"I see such a person in you, if only you go steadily on and bend to your task, and see to it that all your actions and words harmonize and correspond with each other and are stamped in the same mould."

— Seneca, Moral Letters to Lucilius 34

"But how is this done except by principles of thought, concerned both with Universal Nature and with man's individual constitution?"

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 11.05

"Attend to the subject, the activity, the doctrine, or the meaning."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 8.22

"'To what purpose, then, am I now using my soul?' In every case ask yourself this question and examine yourself: 'What have I now in this part which men call the governing part, and whose soul have I at present?"

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 5.11

"From my grandfather Verus: the lessons of noble character and even temper."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 1.01

"Signs of one who is making progress are: He censures no one, praises no one, blames no one, finds fault with no one, says nothing about himself as though he were somebody or knew something."

— Epictetus, The Enchiridion 48

"Habituate yourself not to be inattentive to what another has to say and, so far as possible, be in the mind of the speaker."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 6.53

"At the time of each separate act, stop and ask yourself whether death is to be feared because you are deprived of this."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 10.29

""But," says our opponent, "whatever you do, whatever you are able to give to your father, is part of his benefit bestowed upon you." So it is the benefit of my teacher that I have become proficient in liberal studies; yet we pass on from those who taught them to us, at any rate from those who taught us the alphabet; and although no one can learn anything without them, yet it does not follow that whatsoever success one subsequently obtains, one is still inferior to those teachers."

— Seneca, On Benefits 3.34

"I pray that you may take this my present, such as it is, in good part, and may remember that the others, although they gave you much, yet left for themselves more than they gave." Socrates answered, "Surely you have bestowed a great present upon me, unless perchance you set a small value upon yourself."

— Seneca, On Benefits 1.08

"The writings of the school of Epicurus lay down the injunction to remind oneself continually of one of those who practised virtue in the days gone by."

— Marcus Aurelius, The Meditations 11.26

"Far from being proud, therefore, when somebody says to me, "Read me Chrysippus," I blush the rather, when I am unable to show him such deeds as match and harmonize with his words."

— Epictetus, The Enchiridion 49

"In like manner, dispositions which are naturally bold produce irritability, and, being hot and fiery, have no mean or trivial qualities, but their energy is misdirected, as happens with all those who without training come to the front by their natural advantages alone, whose minds, unless they be brought under control, degenerate from a courageous temper into habits of rashness and reckless daring."

— Seneca, On Anger 2.15

In summary

Nobody in these texts claims to have arrived. The Stoics had a term for the person making progress, the prokopton, and were clear that the perfected sage was a standard rather than an acquaintance. Marcus is writing notes to himself about failing at the same things repeatedly, which is what makes the Meditations useful rather than merely admirable. That is the most transferable thing in the tradition: the assumption is not that you will get this right, but that you will keep returning to it, and that returning is the practice.